In recent years, compressors have been installed in almost all homes. These devices greatly facilitate domestic, commercial, and industrial tasks. Compressors can be of several types. A detailed comparison of a single-stage vs. two-stage air compressor will be described in this article.
Contents
The difference between single-stage air compressors and two-stage compressors
To determine the difference between devices, a detailed comparison of a single-stage vs. two-stage air compressor will help. The main difference is that they have a different number of stages that start the compression process.
If it is the single-stage compressor, then the compressed air is supplied to the intake valves only once.
After that, the compressed air is directed to the storage unit or to the outlet itself. Two-stage models compressed air several times as the pressure increases.
Single-stage compressors are used in small applications and run on gas. If the air compressor is a two-stage unit, it is powered by electricity and is optimal for large applications that require compressed air.
Determining the number of compressor steps
The easiest way to determine this indicator is by studying the dimensions of the cylinders. You can also count the compressed air intake.
If the compressor is a single-stage, its cylinders do not differ in size. All of them have their inlets. Two-stage air compressors have uneven cylinders and only one intake valve.
Features of single-stage compressors
If you plan to choose such a single-stage air compressor, it makes sense to pay attention to some parameters.
Such air compressors can be used in the field of wood or metal processing.
Wood processing
Single-stage air compressors are found in most electric tools, including drills, pneumatic saws, and grinders. They help to accurately cut, process, and assemble wood.
Metal processing
Almost all single-stage compressors that are used daily use metal components. To form such components, various tools are required that will cut, shape, and assemble parts. At the same time, they air compressors in tensile strength.
Single-stage compressors work quite effectively with metals, regardless of their configuration. They can be used in different ways.
Advantages of single-stage compressors
The main advantages of single-stage compressors include:
- low cost of installation of the single-stage compressor;
- small weight of single-stage compressor;
- the energy efficiency of electric models.
Two-stage air compressors
Such options have certain areas of application. More about them will be discussed below.
Repair and assembly of machines
Such devices are always found in car factories. After all, they facilitate the production process.
Devices can lift various components of the car, including cylindrical blocks, frames, and casings. Two-stage compressors help to fix and tighten bolts, as well as to finish the surface with paint.
Aerospace
Two-stage compressors will be very useful in aerospace applications. They make the aircraft manufacturing process easier.
In particular, they can forge components as well as cut them. Compressors can be engaged in machining, assembly, shaping, and finishing work.
Food production
As you know, a large number of products are being prepared and already packed in factories. For commercial purposes, the use of two-stage air compressors will be very effective. They can mix, cut, fill and seal products.
The air compressor can also label and package products. Therefore, people do not have to do everything on their own.
Advantages of two-stage compressors
The main advantages of the air compressor are:
- high-performance;
- less heat generation, so the air compressor cools down;
- this air compressor is the best option for dimensional applications.
What is the optimal number of compressor stages?
It must be understood that the application depends on the number of stages in the air compressor.
If you plan on doing a simple job that one master can do, a single-stage compressor will suffice. If a large production is planned, dual-stage air compressors are appropriate.
Electricity cost factor
Quite often, people pay attention to how much electricity will be consumed. On average, electricity costs will be about 75% of the total cost of the air compressor. If you use two-stage compressors for a long time, you can save a lot in the future.
If your company works every day, 24 hours a day, then the working time per year will be 8,736 hours. During this time, about 35315 ft³ will be spent.
On average, the cost of one kWh is 10 cents. After that, there will be several options for the development of events.
In the first version, the single-stage air compressor will have a capacity of 250 horsepower. It consumes 1029 ft³, or 125 pounds per square inch, every minute. At full load, the air compressor consumes 212.6 kW, and the efficiency is 96%. The cost is about 65 thousand dollars.
In the second option, the two-stage air compressor has a capacity of 200 horsepower. Every minute, it expends 125 pounds per 1 square inch. At full load, consumption is 188 kW. The efficiency is 96%, and the cost is 78 thousand dollars.
The one-step air compressor is quite effective and will be an economical option. However, it is better to dwell on mechanical two-stage options.
It is not difficult to make a cost for 1 year for electricity if you apply a simple formula.
For a single-stage compressor with 250 horsepower, you will have to pay $193,400 every year. But the operation of a two-stage compressor will cost you 171 thousand dollars.
As you can see, if you use the one-stage model, you will overpay about 22.3 thousand dollars during the year.
Therefore, to save money, it is better to opt for compressors with two stages. Thanks to such savings, you can fully recoup the purchase of the air compressor in the first 3 years.
It is important to note one more important advantage of the two-stage technology. Its essence is that it has a very durable screw head.
Reasons for the durability of a two-stage compressor
If you combine the economy of a two-stage air compressor with its longevity, you can save big in the future. However, it is recommended that you only buy instruments from manufacturers that are part of the CAGI Performance Verification Program. This will guarantee performance.
Durability is determined by the fact that an excellent compression ratio is provided, as well as traction load. The compression ratio is determined by the ratio of the discharge pressure to the inlet valve. Absolute pressure refers to atmospheric and gauge pressure.
Absolute pressurized air can be determined using a certain formula. You need to add the gauge and atmospheric pressure, after which the resulting amount is divided by atmospheric pressure. Compressing air occurs along the length of the compressor part and has pressure on the rotor area.
An axle load is formed, which will be completely proportional to the compression ratio. To achieve a pressure of 100 psi, at an atmospheric pressure of 14.7 psi, the compression ratio would be at 7.8. You will need to compress 1 cubic foot of air 7.8 times to get the desired pressure.
The higher the compression ratio, the greater the axial load that is directed to the screw bearings. If you use two-stage air compressors, then the compressed air will be about 3.1 in the first stage, but 2.5 in the second. The lower the compression ratio, the less load is placed on the bearings.
Therefore, the air compressor is durable, reliable, and has a long service life.
FAQ
In the process of comparing a single-stage and two-stage compressor, various questions may arise. The answers to them will be presented below.
What is better, a 2-stage or a single-stage air compressor?
Air compressors with two stages will be the most efficient. In doing so, they cool less and help to get more cubic feet per minute.
What is the advantage of a 2-stage compressor?
Quite often, people try to determine the benefits of a two-stage compressor. They produce more power, so they are appropriate for large operations. You can use them on an ongoing basis, without interruption.
However, their cost is quite high. Therefore, they are often bought by enterprises and workshops to make compressed air more effective.
Are two-stage compressors worth it?
Yes, you can use it. Especially if you have an initial budget. Such devices are very effective, regardless of the purpose. The appliance reduces energy consumption. It makes it easier to monitor environmental performance.
What is the advantage of a single-stage compressor?
Of the advantages, it should be noted low cost, as well as the possibility of saving on energy. At the same time, the devices are light in weight, which facilitates their operation.
Results
As you can see, there are quite significant differences between single-stage and two-stage air compressors. Almost all of them are in power, as well as the cost of paying electricity bills. Wonder Can you use 10w30 in my air compressor, read
